
I wrote this book review for the BCT Newsletter and I wanted to share it. I love these two books!
Phelan, Thomas W. 1-2-3 Magic: Effective Discipline for Children 2-12
Karp, Harvey Happiest Toddler on the Block
My son, Joel, just turned two. This is a polite way of saying that my mild mannered delightful child had slightly shifted. It is true that he is still a marvelous child, it is just that he had developed a little bit more of an opinion about, well, everything! As a former teacher, I thought that I could handle this new step with finesse and tact. As it turns out, what works with 13 year olds does not work as well with two year olds. However, I feel like I was very lucky to have friends with wonderful kids who are not afraid to share their secrets. In this case, the secret included two books: 1-2-3 Magic and The Happiest Toddler on the Block. I have to admit that I read both books over break and I have already seen results.
The first book that I read was, The Happiest Toddler on the Block. I found it to be a fast and fun read (for a parenting book). Dr. Karp, a practicing pediatrician, has written a book that allows you to see the world from your kid’s point of view. While a few of his ideas do seem a little silly, when I put them into practice I saw results. The author advocates some really fun and innovative ideas like introducing “pillow talk” and “personal stories.” I will summarize these two ideas, but keep in mind that the book is full of great strategies for getting your child to feel like they are winning and still accomplish your goals.
Pillow talk includes spending some time before bed just talking about all of the positive things that happened during the day and all of the exciting things that will happen the next day. Joel loves summarizing his day and it is funny to hear him talk about the events that he thinks are important. For example today, right before bed, he told me all about the wind and all the things it blew over. He also loves talking about things that we have done throughout the week. This also gives me time to explain to Joel what is going to happen the next day. I think that he likes to know his agenda just like I appreciate knowing mine. Plus, since we have started doing this, Joel wakes up excited about who he is going to see and what he is going to do.
The personal stories are also a really neat idea. It involves telling your child stories about things that you think are important for them to learn. Dr. Karp explains that you need to be just like Aesop. The key is come up with really fun and interesting non-human characters, use lots of descriptive words, make sure that your content is not scary, and that end the end there is a moral. My husband and I tend to make sure the conflict in the story parallels some conflict we are having with Joel. We like to focus on actions that could have positive and negative consequences. We have told stories about throwing things down the stairs, throwing food, putting on hats, holding hands in the road, etc. One of our favorite stories was about “Muffin the Mouse who hates mittens, but who needs to wear them so she can play with her manatee friends on the Matterhorn snow drifts.” Joel seems to like these stories a great deal and he even has started requesting certain characters. He really loves the Okapi who can fix anything that is broken.
The nice thing about this book is that there are probably a dozen techniques like this that you toddler will love. I know that I am planning on keeping this book on my shelf as a reference. I would recommend it to anyone.
1-2-3 Magic: Effective Discipline for Children 2-12
The other book that I read was 1-2-3 Magic: Effective Discipline for Children 2-12. This book came highly recommended to me by my old pediatrician and several of my friends and former colleagues. They all said that this book will work, though it is more of an owner’s manual than a novel. As I read it, it reminded me of what I would have done in my classroom with my students. The idea could not be simpler and the key to the simplicity is consistency and calmness. The author, Dr. Thomas Phelan, is a child psychologist who explains that you have to set perimeters and then (this is the key) stick to it. You can’t make exceptions and under no circumstances may you lose your temper. You have to be the adult. Kids love to watch you melt down. You have to stay calm under pressure, otherwise, you should sell tickets and pop-corn because your child loves to watch you blow.
The great thing about this book is that it is a step-by-step manual for how to parent during the tougher situations. He spends the majority of the book explaining the steps to timeouts. I was so glad to have this very clearly discussed. I have tried timeouts with Joel and I found them ineffective and I felt guilty that he cried. This book outlines exactly what you need to do and it waylays any guilt that you might feel. I am so glad that I have had the chance to read this book so that I have a plan. Since we have started using the book, my son Joel has gone to time out and I am seeing changes. This book is not magic, but it is a very simple and proven strategy to make sure that your household is run by you. From teaching, I know that kids love and need structure. I hope to use this book as the frame in which to raise a very confident and happy child and will always have a place on my book shelf. I think that I might even by a copy for my next classroom.
Overall, I would say that it makes sense to read these two books together. The complement each other very well. 1-2-3 Magic is like the bones of raising a child. It is clearly written and it is just fundamentally sound. The Happiest Toddler is a wonderful book full of lots of new and interesting ideas on how to foster cooperation and fun into parenting.